After discussing the matter some with KM and hearing what Kax has had to say, they've won me over. The important thing here isn't Alec (who had fair warning, a week to change his pick, and a teammate who, if he's really that concerned about their score, ought to have been watching his back), it's that a precedent would be set. Kax and KM wouldn't know when they have to play babysitter and push a number back to something that "makes sense," or when it's a "small enough mistake" that it should be allowed to stand.

Capping at 100 makes good sense though, and Alec should be happy that they went retroactive and applied that much of a change for him. Since it is, after all, 55% more than he deserved.

---
The 2007 Guru Rankings! thengamer.com/guru
thengamer.com/xstats = lol x-stats