Here are all the people with more than 1 individual top 5 this contest. There are 51 other people who've been in the top 5 once.

Starion - 6
DaruniaTheGoron - 4
ps2rulezzz - 4
Mega Mana - 4
MegatokyoEd - 4
KingBartz - 4
supdawg - 3
Haste2 - 3
Paratroopa1 - 3
Eggplant Lord - 3
Lieutenant Kettch - 3
Cokes - 3
KleenexTissue50 - 3
transience - 3
somdude04 - 3
Lopen - 2
BlAcK TuRtLe - 2
_Harmonica_ - 2
oneills1 - 2
Ayvuir - 2
daniel2424 - 2
GoldSlime35 - 2
capatillistpiglet - 2
MoogleKupo141 - 2
satai_delenn - 2
Tomoyo - 2
Vlado - 2
BeTheMan - 2
jonthomson - 2
Who Cares? - 2
basmeyer42 - 2
StopPokingMe - 2
Explicit Content - 2
yazzy14 - 2
hochiminh155 - 2
ActJef1077 - 2
Lady Ashe - 2
raytan7585 - 2
Master Moltar - 2
---
R.I.P. Robert Jordan, 1948-2007