| Match #3 - Batman: Arkham Asylum vs Psychonauts |
Winner: Batman: Arkham Asylum - 72.50%
|
| Rank | Name | Points | Change | Gap | Average | # | Pick #1 | Pick #2 |
 | 1) | Tazzy Boy Is The One Above All | 263.50 | +90.24 | 0.00 | 87.83 | (3) |
 3 | 2) | Sleep Deprivation | 261.79 | +99.61 | -1.71 | 87.26 | (3) |
| 4 | 3) | Linkhatesgitanil | 257.51 | +96.32 | -5.99 | 85.84 | (3) |
| 6 | 4) | Battle with Gilgamesh < JENOVA | 256.13 | +95.99 | -7.37 | 85.38 | (3) |
 3 | 5) | woozle wuzzle? | 256.08 | +91.35 | -7.42 | 85.36 | (3) |
| 6) | Predestined Divination | 255.71 | +93.75 | -7.79 | 85.24 | (3) |
| 12 | 7) | Berland | 254.67 | +97.34 | -8.83 | 84.89 | (3) |
| 1 | 8) | FOR ASS AND ALLAH | 254.66 | +94.15 | -8.84 | 84.89 | (3) |
| 8 | 9) | Critical Thinkers | 254.30 | +96.14 | -9.20 | 84.77 | (3) |
| 5 | 10) | Prodigy | 253.66 | +95.20 | -9.84 | 84.55 | (3) |
| 7 | 11) | Mee | 253.62 | +90.28 | -9.88 | 84.54 | (3) |
| 4 | 12) | Edward Spiral | 252.51 | +91.44 | -10.99 | 84.17 | (3) |
| 8 | 13) | Kirby | 251.58 | +96.52 | -11.92 | 83.86 | (3) |
| 6 | 14) | Metal Paul | 251.35 | +96.13 | -12.15 | 83.78 | (3) |
| 10 | 15) | Klonoa Alliance | 251.32 | +97.35 | -12.18 | 83.77 | (3) |
| 11 | 16) | Tam | 250.33 | +97.19 | -13.17 | 83.44 | (3) |
| 5 | 17) | Umineko Fujibayashi | 249.63 | +90.27 | -13.87 | 83.21 | (3) |
| 4 | 18) | Moderator Hero | 249.48 | +91.00 | -14.02 | 83.16 | (3) |
| 8 | 19) | Happy Happyists | 249.40 | +89.59 | -14.10 | 83.13 | (3) |
| 2 | 20) | Tie Physics | 248.98 | +94.00 | -14.52 | 82.99 | (3) |
| 10 | 21) | Klackxon! | 248.48 | +98.50 | -15.02 | 82.83 | (3) |
| 8 | 22) | Fortress 2 | 248.47 | +96.79 | -15.03 | 82.82 | (3) |
| 9 | 23) | Berners-Lee | 247.11 | +97.31 | -16.39 | 82.37 | (3) |
| 21 | 24) | Rabid Sea Squirrels | 246.53 | +82.55 | -16.97 | 82.18 | (3) |
| 9 | 25) | Mothy | 246.44 | +88.05 | -17.06 | 82.15 | (3) |
| 7 | 26) | Final Kaontdown | 245.22 | +95.68 | -18.28 | 81.74 | (3) |
| 1 | 27) | Consistently Inconsistent | 244.56 | +91.24 | -18.94 | 81.52 | (3) |
| 28) | Palace of Wisdom | 244.39 | +92.45 | -19.11 | 81.46 | (3) |
| 16 | 29) | Risky | 244.23 | +85.02 | -19.27 | 81.41 | (3) |
| 7 | 30) | Erudite Insight | 242.01 | +87.33 | -21.49 | 80.67 | (3) |
| 3 | 31) | iS33 | 240.82 | +91.69 | -22.68 | 80.27 | (3) |
| 5 | 32) | High Standard | 240.54 | +93.43 | -22.96 | 80.18 | (3) |
| 15 | 33) | McCluster**** | 239.76 | +81.70 | -23.74 | 79.92 | (3) |
| 4 | 34) | No Fighting in the War Room | 239.54 | +94.37 | -23.96 | 79.85 | (3) |
| 6 | 35) | Missing A Match or Two Is Mmkay | 239.48 | +87.75 | -24.02 | 79.83 | (3) |
| 5 | 36) | Buktu | 238.47 | +96.81 | -25.03 | 79.49 | (3) |
| 2 | 37) | Concede You! Wack Predictors | 236.41 | +93.17 | -27.09 | 78.80 | (3) |
| 4 | 38) | Rocksteadily Unsteady | 235.97 | +94.55 | -27.53 | 78.66 | (3) |
| 3 | 39) | Unholy Mackerel | 234.40 | +87.09 | -29.10 | 78.13 | (3) |
| 40) | Allen | 233.81 | +91.53 | -29.69 | 77.94 | (3) |
| 6 | 41) | No More Lynches | 231.27 | +82.76 | -32.23 | 77.09 | (3) |
| 18 | 42) | Percentile Dysfunction | 231.20 | +76.56 | -32.30 | 77.07 | (3) |
| 43) | British Clique | 226.02 | +86.39 | -37.48 | 75.34 | (3) |
| 44) | StopPokingYesmar | 223.50 | +84.32 | -40.00 | 74.50 | (3) |
| 45) | Missionary Visionaries | 221.81 | +88.82 | -41.69 | 73.94 | (3) |
| 46) | IhatehannyaBAL | 216.35 | +87.34 | -47.15 | 72.12 | (3) |