| Contest | Day | Prediction | Winner | Score |
| SC2k15 | 22 | Mass Effect 3 over Undertale with 74.00% | Undertale with 50.95% | 20.05 |
| SC2k10 | 22 | No Mercy over Fire Emblem: Path with 50.50% | Fire Emblem: Path with 71.73% | 22.77 |
| SC2k10 | 56 | The Sims over SotC with 50.01% | SotC with 69.35% | 25.64 |
| SC2k15 | 20 | The Walking Dead over Uncharted 2 with 50.01% | Uncharted 2 with 66.86% | 28.13 |
| SC2k15 | 58 | Borderlands 2 over Earthbound with 55.55% | Earthbound with 58.62% | 30.83 |
| SC2k11 | 22 | Commander Shepard vs Saren Arterius over Alucard vs Dracula with 50.01% | Alucard vs Dracula with 63.23% | 31.76 |
| SC2k11 | 15 | Chris Redfield vs Albert Wesker over Dan vs Sagat with 61.00% | Chris Redfield vs Albert Wesker with 79.22% | 31.78 |
| SC2k15 | 113 | Chrono Trigger over SSBM with 62.26% | SSBM with 50.76% | 31.98 |
| SC2k15 | 101 | Pokemon R/B over Sonic 2 with 60.06% | Pokemon R/B with 78.04% | 32.02 |
| SC2k11 | 37 | Red vs Blue over Luigi vs Waluigi with 60.00% | Red vs Blue with 77.96% | 32.04 |
| SC2k15 | 73 | SMB 3 over Pokemon R/B with 50.05% | Pokemon R/B with 62.67% | 32.28 |
| SC2k11 | 14 | Terra Branford vs Kefka Palazzo over Vyse vs Galcian with 61.00% | Terra Branford vs Kefka Palazzo with 78.66% | 32.34 |
| SC2k10 | 21 | Pokemon D/P over Metroid Fusion with 72.10% | Pokemon D/P with 55.04% | 32.94 |
| SC2k10 | 10 | Devil May Cry 3 over Mother 3 with 81.50% | Devil May Cry 3 with 64.86% | 33.36 |
| SC2k15 | 33 | Zelda: OoT over Hearthstone with 75.00% | Zelda: OoT with 91.03% | 33.97 |
| SC2k11 | 12 | Yuna vs Seymour Guado over Fox McCloud vs Wolf O'Donnell with 50.05% | Fox McCloud vs Wolf O'Donnell with 60.92% | 34.03 |
| SC2k15 | 87 | Super Mario Galaxy over Super Metroid with 51.15% | Super Metroid with 59.59% | 34.26 |
| SC2k15 | 12 | Zelda: WW over Pokemon X/Y with 57.00% | Zelda: WW with 72.60% | 34.40 |
| SC2k10 | 18 | Warcraft III over Morrowind with 60.00% | Morrowind with 50.45% | 34.55 |
| SC2k11 | 7 | Ezio vs Rodrigo over Donkey Kong vs King K. Rool with 50.05% | Donkey Kong vs King K. Rool with 60.20% | 34.75 |
| SC2k11 | 50 | X vs Zero over Sub-Zero vs Scorpion with 67.76% | X vs Zero with 52.70% | 34.94 |
| SC2k11 | 43 | Alucard vs Dracula over Phoenix Wright vs Miles Edgeworth with 71.17% | Alucard vs Dracula with 56.67% | 35.50 |
| SC2k15 | 26 | Diablo II over Goldeneye with 53.50% | Goldeneye with 55.93% | 35.57 |
| SC2k15 | 38 | Fire Emblem: Awakening over Super Mario Maker with 50.01% | Fire Emblem: Awakening with 64.39% | 35.62 |
| SC2k15 | 121 | FF VII over SSBM with 52.25% | SSBM with 56.28% | 36.47 |
| SC2k10 | 74 | CoD4 over Perfect Dark with 68.86% | CoD4 with 55.43% | 36.57 |
| SC2k15 | 19 | Portal 2 over Sonic 2 with 55.00% | Sonic 2 with 53.18% | 36.82 |
| SC2k15 | 127 | Zelda: OoT over Undertale with 50.00% | Undertale with 57.82% | 37.18 |
| SC2k15 | 40 | Castlevania: SotN over Phoenix Wright: TT with 62.25% | Castlevania: SotN with 74.99% | 37.26 |
| SC2k15 | 76 | SMW over FF8 with 55.55% | SMW with 68.25% | 37.30 |
| SC2k15 | 83 | Fire Emblem: Awakening over DKC2 with 55.55% | DKC2 with 52.11% | 37.34 |
| SC2k15 | 86 | MGS 5 over Dark Souls with 52.25% | Dark Souls with 55.40% | 37.35 |
| SC2k15 | 30 | RE2 over FF Tactics with 50.05% | FF Tactics with 57.58% | 37.37 |
| SC2k10 | 2 | RB2 over Deus Ex with 56.78% | Deus Ex with 50.76% | 37.46 |
| SC2k10 | 75 | Pokemon D/P over Fire Emblem: Path with 52.25% | Pokemon D/P with 64.79% | 37.46 |
| SC2k11 | 41 | Link vs Ganondorf over Amaterasu vs Orochi with 71.17% | Link vs Ganondorf with 83.69% | 37.48 |
| SC2k15 | 8 | The Last of Us over Halo 3 with 55.00% | The Last of Us with 67.50% | 37.50 |
| SC2k10 | 23 | Disgaea over Valkyria Chronicles with 55.00% | Valkyria Chronicles with 52.41% | 37.59 |
| SC2k11 | 4 | Sonic vs Robotnik over Katherine vs Catherine with 85.50% | Sonic vs Robotnik with 73.12% | 37.62 |
| SC2k10 | 50 | NSMBW over MvC2 with 55.55% | MvC2 with 51.56% | 37.89 |
| SC2k15 | 37 | Xenoblade Chronicles over DKC2 with 56.65% | DKC2 with 50.36% | 37.99 |
| SC2k15 | 119 | RE4 over Super Mario RPG with 51.15% | Super Mario RPG with 55.53% | 38.32 |
| SC2k11 | 35 | X vs Zero over Bartz vs Gilgamesh with 65.55% | X vs Zero with 77.20% | 38.35 |
| SC2k15 | 36 | Kingdom Hearts over FF9 with 55.55% | FF9 with 51.09% | 38.36 |
| SC2k11 | 18 | Amaterasu vs Orochi over Tom Nook vs Crazy Redd with 55.55% | Amaterasu vs Orochi with 67.12% | 38.43 |
| SC2k15 | 91 | The Witcher 3 over MGS 2 with 52.25% | MGS 2 with 54.21% | 38.54 |
| SC2k15 | 1 | Chrono Trigger over Ratchet & Clank 3 with 74.44% | Chrono Trigger with 85.85% | 38.59 |
| SC2k10 | 58 | Chrono Cross over Dragon Quest VIII with 50.50% | Chrono Cross with 61.89% | 38.61 |
| SC2k11 | 24 | Frog vs Magus over Raiden vs Vamp with 67.50% | Frog vs Magus with 56.13% | 38.63 |
| SC2k11 | 39 | Samus vs Ridley over Terra Branford vs Kefka Palazzo with 72.10% | Samus vs Ridley with 60.79% | 38.69 |
| SC2k10 | 6 | Sonic Adventure 2 over SF4 with 55.55% | SF4 with 50.75% | 38.70 |
| SC2k15 | 103 | Metroid Prime over Skyrim with 55.55% | Skyrim with 50.64% | 38.81 |
| SC2k15 | 74 | Sonic 2 over Uncharted 2 with 55.55% | Sonic 2 with 66.71% | 38.84 |
| SC2k15 | 2 | Persona 3 over Dragon Quest VIII with 51.25% | Dragon Quest VIII with 54.72% | 39.03 |
| SC2k10 | 32 | Kingdom Hearts over Castlevania:DoS with 66.25% | Kingdom Hearts with 76.90% | 39.35 |
| SC2k10 | 7 | Mario Sunshine over Halo 3 with 53.01% | Halo 3 with 52.53% | 39.46 |
| SC2k11 | 49 | Mario vs Bowser over Sonic vs Robotnik with 60.06% | Mario vs Bowser with 70.58% | 39.48 |
| SC2k15 | 117 | Zelda: OoT over Castlevania: SotN with 57.75% | Zelda: OoT with 68.18% | 39.57 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Isaac (BOI) over Tingle with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Isaac (BOI) over Link with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Tingle over Isaac (BOI) with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Tingle over Link with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Link over Isaac (BOI) with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k13 | 1 | Link over Tingle with 0.00% | Link with 72.67% | 40.00 |
| SC2k10 | 4 | Team Fortress 2 over Fable with 59.99% | Team Fortress 2 with 50.03% | 40.04 |
| SC2k15 | 14 | Super Mario Galaxy 2 over Mass Effect with 54.00% | Mass Effect with 50.83% | 40.17 |
| SC2k15 | 65 | Chrono Trigger over Dragon Quest VIII with 72.27% | Chrono Trigger with 81.93% | 40.34 |
| SC2k15 | 126 | Zelda: OoT over Super Mario RPG with 57.75% | Zelda: OoT with 67.38% | 40.37 |
| SC2k15 | 112 | MGS3 over Mass Effect 2 with 51.15% | MGS3 with 60.64% | 40.51 |
| SC2k11 | 9 | Red vs Blue over Raynor vs Kerrigan with 67.50% | Red vs Blue with 76.92% | 40.58 |
| SC2k15 | 108 | LoZ:MM over Super Metroid with 59.95% | LoZ:MM with 50.53% | 40.58 |
| SC2k15 | 72 | FF VII over Halo with 68.86% | FF VII with 78.21% | 40.65 |
| SC2k11 | 38 | Ryu vs Ken over Fox McCloud vs Wolf O'Donnell with 55.75% | Ryu vs Ken with 64.98% | 40.77 |
| SC2k15 | 16 | FF VII over Journey with 75.00% | FF VII with 84.07% | 40.93 |
| SC2k15 | 24 | SMW over Animal Crossing New Leaf with 82.28% | SMW with 73.27% | 40.99 |
| SC2k15 | 77 | Skyrim over Goldeneye with 50.05% | Skyrim with 59.05% | 41.00 |
| SC2k11 | 36 | Sub-Zero vs Scorpion over Donkey Kong vs King K. Rool with 55.55% | Sub-Zero vs Scorpion with 64.48% | 41.07 |
| SC2k10 | 35 | Golden Sun over R&C:UYA with 59.36% | Golden Sun with 68.24% | 41.12 |
| SC2k10 | 59 | Mario Kart Wii over Phoenix Wright with 62.26% | Mario Kart Wii with 53.48% | 41.22 |
| SC2k10 | 54 | Diablo II: LoD over Eternal Darkness with 65.56% | Diablo II: LoD with 74.31% | 41.25 |
| SC2k11 | 6 | Bartz vs Gilgamesh over Guybrush vs LeChuck with 55.55% | Bartz vs Gilgamesh with 64.24% | 41.31 |
| SC2k15 | 53 | The Witcher 3 over Binding of Isaac Rebirth with 65.56% | The Witcher 3 with 74.18% | 41.38 |
| SC2k10 | 27 | Dragon Age over F-Zero GX with 60.77% | Dragon Age with 69.21% | 41.56 |
| SC2k10 | 15 | GTA3 over LittleBigPlanet with 54.05% | GTA3 with 61.98% | 42.07 |
| SC2k15 | 114 | FF VII over FF VI with 52.25% | FF VII with 60.05% | 42.20 |
| SC2k15 | 49 | GTA V over Shenmue with 70.07% | GTA V with 62.35% | 42.28 |
| SC2k11 | 8 | Sub-Zero vs Scorpion over Leon Kennedy vs Ada Wong with 65.56% | Sub-Zero vs Scorpion with 73.22% | 42.34 |
| SC2k15 | 106 | Castlevania: SotN over DKC2 with 54.45% | Castlevania: SotN with 62.03% | 42.42 |
| SC2k15 | 7 | KH2 over MGS4 with 51.15% | KH2 with 58.71% | 42.44 |
| SC2k15 | 92 | RE4 over Fallout: New Vegas with 65.56% | RE4 with 58.11% | 42.55 |
| SC2k15 | 124 | MGS3 over Super Mario RPG with 50.05% | Super Mario RPG with 52.32% | 42.63 |
| SC2k15 | 59 | SotC over Team Fortress 2 with 65.56% | SotC with 72.69% | 42.87 |
| SC2k10 | 48 | Mass Effect over PvZ with 76.67% | Mass Effect with 69.57% | 42.90 |
| SC2k10 | 20 | CoD4 over Prince of Persia SOT with 70.00% | CoD4 with 62.92% | 42.92 |
| SC2k10 | 38 | Fire Emblem over Tony Hawk 2 with 57.50% | Fire Emblem with 64.51% | 42.99 |
| SC2k11 | 20 | Mega Man vs Dr. Wily over Banjo vs Gruntilda with 84.48% | Mega Man vs Dr. Wily with 77.48% | 43.00 |
| SC2k11 | 10 | Luigi vs Waluigi over Cecil vs Golbez with 62.10% | Luigi vs Waluigi with 55.28% | 43.18 |
| SC2k15 | 95 | MGS3 over Bioshock with 58.85% | MGS3 with 52.04% | 43.19 |
| SC2k15 | 66 | FF X over MMX with 62.26% | FF X with 55.48% | 43.22 |
| SC2k10 | 14 | God of War over Left 4 Dead with 58.57% | God of War with 65.29% | 43.28 |
| SC2k11 | 45 | Cloud vs. Sephiroth over Kratos vs Zeus with 70.07% | Cloud vs. Sephiroth with 76.78% | 43.29 |
| SC2k11 | 34 | Sonic vs Robotnik over Kirby vs Meta Knight with 55.55% | Sonic vs Robotnik with 62.21% | 43.34 |
| SC2k10 | 29 | Bioshock over SW Battlefront II with 62.25% | Bioshock with 68.91% | 43.34 |
| SC2k10 | 45 | Portal over Gears of War 2 with 64.82% | Portal with 71.47% | 43.35 |
| SC2k10 | 16 | Half-Life 2 over L4D2 with 67.89% | Half-Life 2 with 74.48% | 43.41 |
| SC2k11 | 21 | Phoenix Wright vs Miles Edgeworth over Gordon Freeman vs Dr. Breen with 50.01% | Phoenix Wright vs Miles Edgeworth with 56.56% | 43.45 |
| SC2k15 | 9 | FF VI over Assassin's Creed II with 70.50% | FF VI with 77.03% | 43.47 |
| SC2k15 | 81 | Zelda: OoT over Suikoden II with 83.38% | Zelda: OoT with 76.89% | 43.51 |
| SC2k10 | 71 | Tales of Symphonia over God of War with 50.00% | God of War with 51.46% | 43.54 |
| SC2k15 | 42 | FF4 over Deus Ex with 63.36% | FF4 with 69.77% | 43.59 |
| SC2k10 | 69 | Metroid Prime over Devil May Cry 3 with 71.00% | Metroid Prime with 64.61% | 43.61 |
| SC2k11 | 1 | Mario vs Bowser over Jim vs Queen Slug-for-a-Butt with 79.00% | Mario vs Bowser with 85.36% | 43.64 |
| SC2k15 | 115 | Undertale over Pokemon R/B with 57.75% | Undertale with 51.52% | 43.77 |
| SC2k15 | 5 | SSBM over Portal with 61.50% | SSBM with 67.71% | 43.79 |
| SC2k15 | 34 | Suikoden II over Monster Hunter 4U with 51.00% | Suikoden II with 56.94% | 44.06 |
| SC2k11 | 2 | Ike vs Black Knight over Conker vs Great Mighty Poo with 53.50% | Ike vs Black Knight with 59.42% | 44.08 |
| SC2k11 | 48 | Dante vs Vergil over Sora vs Riku with 50.01% | Sora vs Riku with 50.85% | 44.14 |
| SC2k10 | 63 | Paper Mario: TYD over Gears of War with 65.56% | Paper Mario: TYD with 59.82% | 44.26 |
| SC2k10 | 57 | LoZ:MM over Wii Sports with 77.70% | LoZ:MM with 83.40% | 44.30 |
| SC2k10 | 8 | Halo over Ninja Gaiden with 58.76% | Halo with 64.45% | 44.31 |
| SC2k15 | 75 | Undertale over Fallout 3 with 50.05% | Undertale with 55.74% | 44.31 |
| SC2k10 | 31 | Modern Warfare 2 over Dissidia with 62.25% | Modern Warfare 2 with 56.61% | 44.36 |
| SC2k15 | 63 | Starcraft over Destiny with 68.86% | Starcraft with 74.49% | 44.37 |
| SC2k15 | 4 | FF X over Half-Life with 69.87% | FF X with 64.42% | 44.55 |
| SC2k15 | 43 | MGS 5 over Perfect Dark with 60.06% | MGS 5 with 54.67% | 44.61 |
| SC2k15 | 118 | Zelda: LttP over LoZ:MM with 57.75% | Zelda: LttP with 52.39% | 44.64 |
| SC2k11 | 32 | Sora vs Riku over Blazkowicz vs Adolf Hitler with 65.56% | Sora vs Riku with 60.21% | 44.65 |
| SC2k15 | 48 | LoZ:MM over Valkyria Chronicles with 81.18% | LoZ:MM with 75.89% | 44.71 |
| SC2k15 | 93 | MGS over Earthbound with 65.56% | MGS with 60.36% | 44.80 |
| SC2k10 | 66 | Batman:AA over Team Fortress 2 with 64.64% | Batman:AA with 59.52% | 44.88 |
| SC2k11 | 42 | Mega Man vs Dr. Wily over Zidane Tribal vs Kuja with 71.17% | Mega Man vs Dr. Wily with 66.11% | 44.94 |
| SC2k10 | 34 | Borderlands over ToV with 50.50% | Borderlands with 55.53% | 44.97 |
| SC2k15 | 35 | Okami over Warcraft III with 65.56% | Okami with 60.59% | 45.03 |
| SC2k15 | 25 | Skyrim over Phoenix Wright with 71.50% | Skyrim with 66.62% | 45.12 |
| SC2k15 | 46 | Super Mario Galaxy over Dragon Age with 68.86% | Super Mario Galaxy with 64.04% | 45.18 |
| SC2k10 | 70 | Okami over MM9 with 61.00% | Okami with 56.31% | 45.31 |
| SC2k15 | 41 | Zelda: LttP over Cave Story with 83.38% | Zelda: LttP with 88.02% | 45.36 |
| SC2k10 | 3 | Batman:AA over Psychonauts with 77.10% | Batman:AA with 72.50% | 45.40 |
| SC2k11 | 40 | Big Boss vs The Boss over Chris Redfield vs Albert Wesker with 61.16% | Big Boss vs The Boss with 56.60% | 45.44 |
| SC2k10 | 25 | Super Mario Galaxy over BG&E with 79.32% | Super Mario Galaxy with 74.79% | 45.47 |
| SC2k11 | 51 | Red vs Blue over Ryu vs Ken with 55.55% | Red vs Blue with 60.04% | 45.51 |
| SC2k11 | 25 | Cloud vs. Sephiroth over Lloyd Irving vs Kratos Aurion with 81.11% | Cloud vs. Sephiroth with 76.64% | 45.53 |
| SC2k15 | 15 | Halo over Minecraft with 52.25% | Halo with 56.72% | 45.53 |
| SC2k15 | 56 | RE4 over Paper Mario with 54.45% | RE4 with 58.87% | 45.58 |
| SC2k10 | 37 | Star Wars: KOTOR over DMC with 62.34% | Star Wars: KOTOR with 58.05% | 45.71 |
| SC2k11 | 52 | Samus vs Ridley over Big Boss vs The Boss with 57.75% | Samus vs Ridley with 53.47% | 45.72 |
| SC2k10 | 40 | FF9 over Phoenix Wright: TT with 70.92% | FF9 with 75.19% | 45.73 |
| SC2k15 | 122 | Undertale over SM 64 with 55.55% | Undertale with 51.33% | 45.78 |
| SC2k11 | 26 | Kratos vs Zeus over Professor Layton vs Don Paolo with 70.00% | Kratos vs Zeus with 74.12% | 45.88 |
| SC2k11 | 16 | Big Boss vs The Boss over Tidus vs Jecht with 55.55% | Big Boss vs The Boss with 59.64% | 45.91 |
| SC2k15 | 90 | Chrono Cross over GTA: San Andreas with 58.85% | Chrono Cross with 54.82% | 45.97 |
| SC2k15 | 79 | SM 64 over FF Tactics with 62.26% | SM 64 with 66.23% | 46.03 |
| SC2k15 | 18 | Pokemon R/B over Tetris with 72.27% | Pokemon R/B with 68.33% | 46.06 |
| SC2k10 | 19 | Perfect Dark over Conker's Bad Fur Day with 60.00% | Perfect Dark with 63.93% | 46.07 |
| SC2k10 | 44 | Persona 4 over Braid with 60.06% | Persona 4 with 63.97% | 46.09 |
| SC2k15 | 45 | Super Metroid over CoD4 with 75.57% | Super Metroid with 79.46% | 46.11 |
| SC2k10 | 62 | Assassin's Creed II over ICO with 65.56% | Assassin's Creed II with 61.89% | 46.33 |
| SC2k15 | 52 | Chrono Cross over WoW with 54.45% | Chrono Cross with 58.06% | 46.39 |
| SC2k10 | 33 | FF X over Viewtiful Joe with 81.00% | FF X with 77.46% | 46.46 |
| SC2k15 | 116 | SM 64 over Skyrim with 57.75% | SM 64 with 61.27% | 46.48 |
| SC2k11 | 27 | Pac-Man vs Blinky over Crash Bandicoot vs Neo Cortex with 60.00% | Pac-Man vs Blinky with 63.51% | 46.49 |
| SC2k15 | 32 | Persona 4 over 999 with 74.47% | Persona 4 with 77.80% | 46.67 |
| SC2k15 | 88 | LoZ:MM over FF12 with 65.56% | LoZ:MM with 68.87% | 46.69 |
| SC2k11 | 47 | Squall vs Seifer over Siegfried vs Nightmare with 70.07% | Squall vs Seifer with 66.76% | 46.69 |
| SC2k15 | 29 | SM 64 over Mario Kart 8 with 83.30% | SM 64 with 80.04% | 46.74 |
| SC2k15 | 57 | MGS over Splatoon with 82.28% | MGS with 79.07% | 46.79 |
| SC2k11 | 19 | Zidane Tribal vs Kuja over Meat Boy vs Dr. Fetus with 67.76% | Zidane Tribal vs Kuja with 64.61% | 46.85 |
| SC2k10 | 64 | Oblivion over SCII with 65.56% | Oblivion with 62.45% | 46.89 |
| SC2k15 | 27 | Metroid Prime over Morrowind with 60.00% | Metroid Prime with 63.09% | 46.91 |
| SC2k10 | 41 | RE4 over Jet Grind Radio with 85.21% | RE4 with 82.15% | 46.94 |
| SC2k15 | 62 | Bioshock over Silent Hill 2 with 64.46% | Bioshock with 61.43% | 46.97 |
| SC2k10 | 11 | MM9 over Demon's Souls with 50.00% | MM9 with 53.00% | 47.00 |
| SC2k15 | 31 | Zelda: Twilight Princess over Skies of Arcadia with 75.25% | Zelda: Twilight Princess with 72.34% | 47.09 |
| SC2k15 | 107 | Zelda: LttP over Dark Souls with 67.76% | Zelda: LttP with 70.58% | 47.18 |
| SC2k11 | 3 | Kirby vs Meta Knight over Jill Valentine vs Nemesis with 55.66% | Kirby vs Meta Knight with 58.47% | 47.19 |
| SC2k10 | 1 | Fallout 3 over inFamous with 78.21% | Fallout 3 with 81.00% | 47.21 |
| SC2k15 | 64 | Mass Effect 2 over Virtue's Last Reward with 75.57% | Mass Effect 2 with 78.08% | 47.49 |
| SC2k11 | 31 | Dante vs Vergil over Sol Badguy vs Ky Kiske with 80.10% | Dante vs Vergil with 82.59% | 47.51 |
| SC2k11 | 46 | Solid Snake vs Liquid Snake over Pac-Man vs Blinky with 70.07% | Solid Snake vs Liquid Snake with 67.64% | 47.57 |
| SC2k15 | 78 | Metroid Prime over Half-Life 2 with 55.55% | Metroid Prime with 57.95% | 47.60 |
| SC2k10 | 42 | GTA: Vice City over Silent Hill 2 with 61.23% | GTA: Vice City with 63.57% | 47.66 |
| SC2k15 | 54 | MGS 2 over Resident Evil with 54.45% | MGS 2 with 56.76% | 47.69 |
| SC2k15 | 70 | Zelda: WW over Star Wars: KOTOR with 65.56% | Zelda: WW with 63.25% | 47.69 |
| SC2k10 | 60 | Pokemon G/S/C over Advance Wars with 75.57% | Pokemon G/S/C with 73.28% | 47.71 |
| SC2k15 | 67 | SSBM over Pokemon G/S with 57.75% | SSBM with 60.03% | 47.72 |
| SC2k10 | 17 | SSBM over GHII with 85.00% | SSBM with 87.16% | 47.84 |
| SC2k10 | 46 | FF12 over Crisis Core with 53.50% | FF12 with 55.65% | 47.85 |
| SC2k10 | 53 | MGS4 over Assassin's Creed with 65.56% | MGS4 with 63.49% | 47.93 |
| SC2k10 | 52 | WoW over Animal Crossing with 56.65% | WoW with 58.55% | 48.10 |
| SC2k15 | 109 | Super Mario RPG over Chrono Cross with 58.85% | Super Mario RPG with 60.74% | 48.11 |
| SC2k15 | 3 | MMX over Batman: Arkham City with 58.85% | MMX with 60.68% | 48.17 |
| SC2k10 | 24 | SSBB over MKDS with 85.00% | SSBB with 83.26% | 48.26 |
| SC2k15 | 60 | Red Dead Redemption over Bayonetta 2 with 62.26% | Red Dead Redemption with 63.99% | 48.27 |
| SC2k11 | 11 | Ryu vs Ken over Ratchet vs Dr. Nefarious with 79.97% | Ryu vs Ken with 81.63% | 48.34 |
| SC2k15 | 89 | Super Mario RPG over GTA V with 58.85% | Super Mario RPG with 57.20% | 48.35 |
| SC2k10 | 61 | Zelda: WW over God of War II with 65.56% | Zelda: WW with 63.95% | 48.39 |
| SC2k10 | 30 | KH2 over Halo 2 with 62.25% | KH2 with 63.81% | 48.44 |
| SC2k11 | 5 | X vs Zero over Captain Falcon vs Black Shadow with 78.90% | X vs Zero with 80.45% | 48.45 |
| SC2k15 | 71 | Smash Bros. Wii U over Mass Effect with 53.35% | Smash Bros. Wii U with 54.89% | 48.46 |
| SC2k15 | 94 | SotC over Red Dead Redemption with 57.75% | SotC with 59.25% | 48.50 |
| SC2k10 | 65 | Fallout 3 over Deus Ex with 75.75% | Fallout 3 with 74.27% | 48.52 |
| SC2k15 | 55 | Fallout: New Vegas over BioShock Infinite with 54.45% | Fallout: New Vegas with 55.92% | 48.53 |
| SC2k11 | 13 | Samus vs Ridley over The Kid vs The Guy with 82.10% | Samus vs Ridley with 80.64% | 48.54 |
| SC2k15 | 21 | Fallout 3 over Life is Strange with 74.00% | Fallout 3 with 72.55% | 48.55 |
| SC2k10 | 12 | Okami over NMH with 70.00% | Okami with 71.41% | 48.59 |
| SC2k10 | 13 | Tales of Symphonia over RE5 with 53.57% | Tales of Symphonia with 52.17% | 48.60 |
| SC2k15 | 69 | FF VI over Paper Mario: TYD with 65.56% | FF VI with 66.94% | 48.62 |
| SC2k10 | 68 | Halo over Halo 3 with 55.55% | Halo with 56.92% | 48.63 |
| SC2k15 | 100 | FF VII over Smash Bros. Wii U with 66.66% | FF VII with 65.29% | 48.63 |
| SC2k11 | 29 | Squall vs Seifer over Laharl vs Mid-Boss with 75.00% | Squall vs Seifer with 73.65% | 48.65 |
| SC2k11 | 23 | Chell vs GLaDOS over Ness vs Giygas with 57.75% | Chell vs GLaDOS with 59.07% | 48.68 |
| SC2k10 | 73 | SSBM over Morrowind with 70.07% | SSBM with 71.39% | 48.68 |
| SC2k15 | 111 | MGS over SotC with 52.25% | MGS with 53.56% | 48.69 |
| SC2k15 | 85 | Zelda: LttP over FF4 with 66.66% | Zelda: LttP with 65.45% | 48.79 |
| SC2k10 | 36 | GTA: San Andreas over Dead Space with 64.28% | GTA: San Andreas with 65.45% | 48.83 |
| SC2k15 | 47 | FF12 over Bloodborne with 54.45% | FF12 with 55.59% | 48.86 |
| SC2k15 | 44 | Dark Souls over Civ V with 65.56% | Dark Souls with 66.70% | 48.86 |
| SC2k15 | 68 | KH2 over The Last of Us with 61.16% | KH2 with 60.03% | 48.87 |
| SC2k11 | 17 | Link vs Ganondorf over Arthas vs Illidan with 84.21% | Link vs Ganondorf with 85.30% | 48.91 |
| SC2k15 | 50 | Super Mario RPG over Oblivion with 53.35% | Super Mario RPG with 54.43% | 48.92 |
| SC2k15 | 125 | Undertale over SSBM with 52.25% | Undertale with 51.20% | 48.95 |
| SC2k15 | 123 | Zelda: OoT over Zelda: LttP with 58.85% | Zelda: OoT with 59.90% | 48.95 |
| SC2k15 | 39 | Banjo-Kazooie over Baldur's Gate II with 63.36% | Banjo-Kazooie with 62.32% | 48.96 |
| SC2k11 | 28 | Solid Snake vs Liquid Snake over Crono vs Lavos with 57.75% | Solid Snake vs Liquid Snake with 58.77% | 48.98 |
| SC2k10 | 47 | Skies of Arcadia over Baldur's Gate II with 53.35% | Skies of Arcadia with 52.40% | 49.05 |
| SC2k10 | 49 | MGS3 over TimeSplitters 2 with 77.77% | MGS3 with 76.85% | 49.08 |
| SC2k15 | 104 | SM 64 over Zelda: Twilight Princess with 57.75% | SM 64 with 56.87% | 49.12 |
| SC2k10 | 76 | SSBB over Valkyria Chronicles with 75.57% | SSBB with 76.44% | 49.13 |
| SC2k10 | 5 | Uncharted 2 over Legend of Dragoon with 58.23% | Uncharted 2 with 57.40% | 49.17 |
| SC2k15 | 11 | Star Wars: KOTOR over Xenogears with 54.45% | Star Wars: KOTOR with 53.65% | 49.20 |
| SC2k15 | 17 | SMB 3 over Age of Empires II with 83.38% | SMB 3 with 84.17% | 49.21 |
| SC2k10 | 26 | Pokemon RSE over GTA4 with 50.01% | Pokemon RSE with 50.77% | 49.24 |
| SC2k15 | 120 | MGS3 over MGS with 51.15% | MGS3 with 51.86% | 49.29 |
| SC2k15 | 102 | Undertale over SMW with 55.55% | Undertale with 54.84% | 49.29 |
| SC2k11 | 30 | Siegfried vs Nightmare over Ramza vs Delita with 55.00% | Siegfried vs Nightmare with 55.68% | 49.32 |
| SC2k15 | 61 | MGS3 over Mother 3 with 68.86% | MGS3 with 69.50% | 49.36 |
| SC2k10 | 72 | Half-Life 2 over GTA3 with 56.78% | Half-Life 2 with 56.17% | 49.39 |
| SC2k10 | 28 | Zelda: Twilight Princess over Shenmue with 78.78% | Zelda: Twilight Princess with 79.38% | 49.40 |
| SC2k15 | 105 | Zelda: OoT over FF9 with 65.56% | Zelda: OoT with 64.96% | 49.40 |
| SC2k10 | 51 | Paper Mario over Katamari Damacy with 72.73% | Paper Mario with 72.14% | 49.41 |
| SC2k15 | 84 | Castlevania: SotN over Banjo-Kazooie with 61.16% | Castlevania: SotN with 60.61% | 49.45 |
| SC2k15 | 28 | Half-Life 2 over Demon's Souls with 63.50% | Half-Life 2 with 63.90% | 49.60 |
| SC2k15 | 99 | FF VI over Zelda: WW with 53.35% | FF VI with 53.75% | 49.60 |
| SC2k10 | 55 | MGS 2 over Banjo-Tooie with 70.07% | MGS 2 with 69.68% | 49.61 |
| SC2k11 | 44 | Frog vs Magus over Chell vs GLaDOS with 51.15% | Frog vs Magus with 51.51% | 49.64 |
| SC2k15 | 23 | FF8 over GTA: Vice City with 61.00% | FF8 with 60.68% | 49.68 |
| SC2k15 | 80 | Zelda: Twilight Princess over Persona 4 with 65.56% | Zelda: Twilight Princess with 65.27% | 49.71 |
| SC2k10 | 43 | Dead Rising over TWEWY with 51.15% | Dead Rising with 50.91% | 49.76 |
| SC2k15 | 13 | Smash Bros. Wii U over Planescape: Torment with 78.85% | Smash Bros. Wii U with 79.05% | 49.80 |
| SC2k10 | 9 | Metroid Prime over Star Ocean 3 with 73.51% | Metroid Prime with 73.34% | 49.83 |
| SC2k10 | 39 | Persona 3 over Civ IV with 52.50% | Persona 3 with 52.35% | 49.85 |
| SC2k15 | 6 | Pokemon G/S over TWEWY with 76.50% | Pokemon G/S with 76.63% | 49.87 |
| SC2k15 | 10 | Paper Mario: TYD over Tales of Symphonia with 52.00% | Paper Mario: TYD with 51.87% | 49.87 |
| SC2k15 | 51 | GTA: San Andreas over Shovel Knight with 61.16% | GTA: San Andreas with 61.28% | 49.88 |
| SC2k15 | 82 | FF9 over Okami with 57.75% | FF9 with 57.85% | 49.90 |
| SC2k15 | 96 | Mass Effect 2 over Starcraft with 51.15% | Mass Effect 2 with 51.13% | 49.98 |
| SC2k15 | 110 | RE4 over MGS 2 with 54.45% | RE4 with 54.44% | 49.99 |
17