| Match #1 - Mario vs. Bowser vs Earthworm Jim vs. Queen Slug-for-a-Butt |
Winner: Mario vs. Bowser - 85.36%
|
| Rank | Name | Points | Change | Gap | Average | # | Pick #1 | Pick #2 |
| NEW | 1) | Voldemort | 99.39 | +99.39 | 0.00 | 99.39 | (1) |
| NEW | 2) | Screaming Great Crustacean Who Collects Blood | 99.01 | +99.01 | -0.38 | 99.01 | (1) |
| NEW | 3) | King Charisma who Was Destined to be a Chef | 98.76 | +98.76 | -0.63 | 98.76 | (1) |
| NEW | 4) | Kirby | 98.43 | +98.43 | -0.96 | 98.43 | (1) |
| NEW | 5) | Palace of Wisdom | 97.79 | +97.79 | -1.60 | 97.79 | (1) |
| NEW | 6) | Heisenbartz and Captain Cokes | 97.71 | +97.71 | -1.68 | 97.71 | (1) |
| NEW | 7) | Benevolent Grand Empress with a Mind of Turquoise | 97.27 | +97.27 | -2.12 | 97.27 | (1) |
| NEW | 8) | Advokacy Basis | 97.10 | +97.10 | -2.29 | 97.10 | (1) |
| NEW | 9) | Indigo Falsehood of Authority and Silence | 96.79 | +96.79 | -2.60 | 96.79 | (1) |
| NEW | 10) | Terra-fic | 96.78 | +96.78 | -2.61 | 96.78 | (1) |
| NEW | 11) | Vicious Illuminated Marquis | 96.49 | +96.49 | -2.90 | 96.49 | (1) |
| NEW | 12) | Happy Happyists | 96.40 | +96.40 | -2.99 | 96.40 | (1) |
| NEW | 13) | Ara-Bro | 96.39 | +96.39 | -3.00 | 96.39 | (1) |
| NEW | 14) | BOTS R HOTS | 96.33 | +96.33 | -3.06 | 96.33 | (1) |
| NEW | 14) | Battle with Gilgamesh < JENOVA | 96.33 | +96.33 | -3.06 | 96.33 | (1) |
| NEW | 16) | 21 Or was it 22? | 96.21 | +96.21 | -3.18 | 96.21 | (1) |
| NEW | 17) | Ice Cream | 96.19 | +96.19 | -3.20 | 96.19 | (1) |
| NEW | 18) | Predestined Divination | 96.11 | +96.11 | -3.28 | 96.11 | (1) |
| NEW | 19) | Predix Shunned | 95.98 | +95.98 | -3.41 | 95.98 | (1) |
| NEW | 20) | Sultan Agility Draped in the Coat of Ghastly Words | 95.79 | +95.79 | -3.60 | 95.79 | (1) |
| NEW | 21) | Knockin' on Victory's Door | 95.78 | +95.78 | -3.61 | 95.78 | (1) |
| NEW | 22) | Zoisite of the Bloody Canyon | 95.20 | +95.20 | -4.19 | 95.20 | (1) |
| NEW | 23) | Otaku Neckbeard Keyboard Warriors | 95.08 | +95.08 | -4.31 | 95.08 | (1) |
| NEW | 24) | Konata x Kagami | 95.01 | +95.01 | -4.38 | 95.01 | (1) |
| NEW | 25) | Golden Ambassador That Plans in the Great Ossuary | 94.84 | +94.84 | -4.55 | 94.84 | (1) |
| NEW | 26) | Leonhart is Dead | 94.16 | +94.16 | -5.23 | 94.16 | (1) |
| NEW | 27) | Rocksteadily Unsteady | 94.00 | +94.00 | -5.39 | 94.00 | (1) |
| NEW | 28) | Forbidden Bodhisattva of Strength | 93.96 | +93.96 | -5.43 | 93.96 | (1) |
| NEW | 29) | Necklace of Carnage with Insurmountable Labyrinth | 93.93 | +93.93 | -5.46 | 93.93 | (1) |
| NEW | 30) | Slaughter of the Crystal Sepulcher | 93.24 | +93.24 | -6.15 | 93.24 | (1) |
| NEW | 31) | RAWR | 92.88 | +92.88 | -6.51 | 92.88 | (1) |
| NEW | 32) | Philosopher with Lips of Nephrite and Ice Stiletto | 91.88 | +91.88 | -7.51 | 91.88 | (1) |
| NEW | 33) | Menjiana Jones and The Last Grapefruit | 91.74 | +91.74 | -7.65 | 91.74 | (1) |
| NEW | 34) | Aurochs | 91.34 | +91.34 | -8.05 | 91.34 | (1) |
| NEW | 35) | Blasphemous Dancer of Dexterity and Water | 91.26 | +91.26 | -8.13 | 91.26 | (1) |
| NEW | 36) | British Alliance | 90.65 | +90.65 | -8.74 | 90.65 | (1) |
| NEW | 37) | T-REX | 88.93 | +88.93 | -10.46 | 88.93 | (1) |
| NEW | 38) | Hitler on the Roof | 88.67 | +88.67 | -10.72 | 88.67 | (1) |
| NEW | 39) | SUMADARTSON | 87.64 | +87.64 | -11.75 | 87.64 | (1) |