| < No Previous Match | Overall Rankings | Match #2 > |
| Match #1 - Super Mario Bros. 3 vs Metal Gear | ||||
| Consensus : | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.59% | ||
| Result : | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.30% | 45.13 | |
| Rank | Name | Pick | Points | |
| 1) | TheCalmness | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.37% | 49.93 |
| 2) | KrusTy the KloWn | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.46% | 49.84 |
| 3) | GunMage | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.50% | 49.80 |
| 4) | solarshadow | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.02% | 49.72 |
| 5) | Dilated Chemist | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 82.90% | 49.40 |
| 6) | Master Moltar | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.64% | 49.34 |
| 7) | Garsha | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.55% | 49.25 |
| 8) | FastFalcon05 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.43% | 49.13 |
| 9) | Sir Shake | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 83.23% | 49.07 |
| 10) | King Morgoth | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.36% | 49.06 |
| 11) | kaonashi1 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.31% | 49.01 |
| 12) | PeaceOut64 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 83.40% | 48.90 |
| 13) | The n00b Avenger | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.17% | 48.87 |
| 14) | kawaiifan | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.00% | 48.70 |
| 14) | Who Cares? | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 81.00% | 48.70 |
| 16) | Ngamer64 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 83.63% | 48.67 |
| 17) | Z1mZum | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 83.78% | 48.52 |
| 18) | Yesmar | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 83.89% | 48.41 |
| 19) | steve illumina | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 84.30% | 48.00 |
| 20) | charmander6000 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.23% | 47.93 |
| 21) | Darkash | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 84.48% | 47.82 |
| 22) | ps2rulezzz | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 84.50% | 47.80 |
| 23) | UltimaterializerX | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 84.55% | 47.75 |
| 24) | creativename | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.00% | 47.70 |
| 24) | Heroic Viktor | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.00% | 47.70 |
| 24) | Sir Chris | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 84.60% | 47.70 |
| 24) | Kosmo Trainer | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.00% | 47.70 |
| 24) | London Prophet | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.00% | 47.70 |
| 24) | torey luvullo | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 80.00% | 47.70 |
| 30) | Slowflake | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 79.95% | 47.65 |
| 31) | CapnAmerica | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 79.23% | 46.93 |
| 32) | Wlokos | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.94% | 46.64 |
| 33) | dlcb1 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.89% | 46.59 |
| 34) | StopPokingMe | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.88% | 46.58 |
| 35) | Scoop Li | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.78% | 46.48 |
| 36) | HyperBlast Xan | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.77% | 46.47 |
| 37) | Alanna82 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.00% | 46.30 |
| 37) | Sephirot1 Returns | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.00% | 46.30 |
| 39) | Rodri316 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.45% | 46.15 |
| 40) | Excal | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.43% | 46.13 |
| 41) | Ringworm | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.19% | 46.11 |
| 42) | GoldSlime35 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.23% | 46.07 |
| 43) | MMXcalibur | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.31% | 45.99 |
| 44) | Cid | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.50% | 45.80 |
| 45) | cyko | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.03% | 45.73 |
| 45) | GANON1025 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 86.57% | 45.73 |
| 47) | Bananaquest | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.01% | 45.71 |
| 48) | Jericoholic | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 78.00% | 45.70 |
| 49) | red sox 777 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 77.77% | 45.47 |
| 50) | franmars | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 77.65% | 45.35 |
| 51) | Forsaken | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 77.64% | 45.34 |
| 52) | Team Rocket Elite | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 87.00% | 45.30 |
| 52) | Blackapino1984 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 87.00% | 45.30 |
| 54) | dethwing | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 87.23% | 45.07 |
| 55) | daniel2424 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 87.24% | 45.06 |
| 56) | Xuxon | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 77.22% | 44.92 |
| 57) | WiggumFan267 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 87.50% | 44.80 |
| 58) | Haste2 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 76.44% | 44.14 |
| 59) | ZetSword | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 88.50% | 43.80 |
| 60) | ReaPeR xZ | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 88.52% | 43.78 |
| 61) | Phediuk | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 76.00% | 43.70 |
| 61) | The Wise Tonberry | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 76.00% | 43.70 |
| 61) | nh82 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 76.00% | 43.70 |
| 64) | GeniusMan86 | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 89.34% | 42.96 |
| 65) | Albasuna | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 75.00% | 42.70 |
| 65) | Qwaar | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 75.00% | 42.70 |
| 67) | bjgood | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 90.19% | 42.11 |
| 68) | devil night hawk | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 90.27% | 42.03 |
| 69) | Dasmopp | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 74.00% | 41.70 |
| 70) | Holy Excalibur | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 72.00% | 39.70 |
| 71) | Tequilla Gundam | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 71.93% | 39.63 |
| 72) | bj good | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 93.23% | 39.07 |
| 73) | Heroic Mario | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 93.47% | 38.83 |
| 74) | Lieutenant Kettch | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 71.00% | 38.70 |
| 75) | Rzrsk8er | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 70.23% | 37.93 |
| 76) | DaruniaTheKing | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 70.01% | 37.71 |
| 77) | Starion | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 69.50% | 37.20 |
| 78) | swirldude | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 67.83% | 35.53 |
| 79) | neoatomtaco | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 67.80% | 35.50 |
| 80) | ChichiriMuyo | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 65.00% | 32.70 |
| 81) | TrunksMagusDante | Super Mario Bros. 3 | 63.22% | 30.92 |